Pie Cherries Vs. Regular Cherries: Best Cherry Varieties For Pie

Closeup of a slice of cherry pie
Image by chas53

By Liz Baessler

Not all cherry trees are the same. There are two main varieties – sour and sweet – and each has its own uses. While sweet cherries are sold in grocery stores and eaten straight, sour cherries are hard to eat on their own and not usually sold fresh in grocery stores. You can bake a pie with sweet cherries, but pies are what sour (or tart) cherries are made for. Keep reading to learn more about what kind of cherries are good for pies.

Pie Cherries vs. Regular Cherries

The main difference when it comes to pie cherries vs. regular cherries is the amount of sugar you’ll have to use. Pie cherries, or sour cherries, are not nearly as sweet as the cherries you buy to eat, and have to be sweetened with a lot of extra sugar.

If you’re following a recipe, see if it specifies whether you need sweet or sour cherries. Often your recipe will have sour cherries in mind. You can substitute one for the other, but you’ll have to adjust the sugar, too. Otherwise, you could end up with a pie that’s cloyingly sweet or inedibly sour.

Additionally, sour pie cherries are normally juicier than sweet cherries, and may result in a runnier pie unless you add a little cornstarch.

Sour Pie Cherries


Sour pie cherries aren’t usually sold fresh, but you can usually find them in the grocery store canned specifically for pie filling. Or try going to a farmer’s market. Then again, you could always grow your own sour cherry tree.

Sour pie cherries can be broken into two main categories: Morello and Amarelle. Morello cherries have dark red flesh. Amarelle cherries have yellow to clear flesh and are the most popular. Montmorency, a variety of Amarelle cherry, makes up 95% of the sour pie cherries sold in North America.

Print This Article
This article was last updated on
Did you find this helpful?
Share it with your friends!

Additional Help & Information

Didn't find the answer to your question? Ask one of our friendly gardening experts.

Do you know anything about gardening? Help answer someone's gardening question.

Read more articles about Cherry Trees.

Search for more information

Use the search box below to find more gardening information on Gardening Know How: