Onion Bulb Formation: Why Onions Do Not Form Bulbs

onion with no bulb
Image by humonia

By Amy Grant

Many onion varieties are available to the home gardener and most are relatively easy to grow. That said, onions do have their fair share of issues with onion bulb formation; either the onions don’t form bulbs, or they may be small and/or misshapen.

Reasons for No Onion Bulbs

One possible reason for a lack of onion bulb formation is the selection of the wrong type of onion for your area. In their natural environment, onions are biennials that have a two-year life cycle. The first year, the plant bulbs and the second year it flowers. Cultivators of onions grow them as an annual and harvest at the end of the first growing season.


Onions are categorized as “long day” or “short day” varieties, with some intermediate varieties available as well. The terms are in reference to the length of daylight during the growing season in a particular area.

  • A “long day” onion variety quits forming leaves and begins to bulb when the length of daylight is 14-16 hours.
  • “Short day” cultivars make bulbs much earlier in the season when daylight is only 10-12 hours long.

“Long day” onions should be planted north of the 40th parallel (San Francisco on the west coast and Washington D.C. on the east) while “short day” onions do best south of the 28th parallel (New Orleans, Miami).

The newest kids on the block are the day neutral varieties of onion which can be planted without regard to latitude — a big boon to gardeners between the 28th and 40th parallel.

Bulb size is in direct correlation to the number and size of leaves (tops) of the onion at the time of bulb maturity. Each leaf corresponds to a ring of the onion and the larger the leaf, the larger the ring.

How to Get Onions to Form a Bulb

Choosing an appropriate onion variety for your region and following the correct planting time is an important factor in getting healthy onion bulbs to form. “Long day” varieties are planted in the early spring. Either start seeds indoors and transplant or plant onion sets directly outdoors. “Short day” cultivars should be planted mid fall either directly sown or with onion sets.

Grow onions in raised beds about 4 inches high and 20 inches across. Dig a 4-inch trench in the bed and distribute a phosphorus rich fertilizer (10-20-10) 2 or 3 inches below the transplants, cover with a couple of inches of soil and plant the onion sets.

Maintain some space between the plants, 1 inch deep and 4 inches apart. For direct sown onion, thinning is the key to bulb size. Obviously, if there isn’t room to grow, you’ll get onions that don’t form adequate bulbs.

Lastly, while this may not be directly related to a lack of bulbing, temperature will most certainly affect the size and quality of the onion. Cooler temps below 70 F. (21 C.) may retard bulbing in some varieties. In late spring, fluctuation between warm days alternating with cool days may cause the plant to bolt, or flower. Flowering in onions results in a lighter weight bulb with an increased risk of decay and a lower storage life.

Print This Article
This article was last updated on
Did you find this helpful?
Share it with your friends!

Additional Help & Information

Didn't find the answer to your question? Ask one of our friendly gardening experts.

Do you know anything about gardening? Help answer someone's gardening question.

Read more articles about Onions.

Search for more information

Use the search box below to find more gardening information on Gardening Know How: