Transform Your Soil with These 6 Surprising Foodie Scraps – Gourmet Goodness to Boost Next Year’s Beds

Fall kitchens turn out some odd waste. Shrimp shells from a weekend boil, rinds left over from juicing, bread that went stale before anyone got to it: these food scraps usually end up in the trash on the assumption they won’t break down, or that they'll draw something unwelcome into the yard. But there’s some surprising gourmet treats lurking at the bottom of your trash can that can work wonders recycled in the yard.

When it comes to kitchen waste that can nourish our soil, coffee grounds, eggshells, banana skins, used tea leaves, and vegetable peelings get most of the attention. While those staples have their place in the compost pile, there are other treasures hiding in plain sight in our trash, and these unexpected foodie scraps are just begging to be put to good use.

Fall is the perfect time for composting some of this more complex, dense kitchen waste. A compost heap you get to work now has all winter and early spring to quietly work through these materials. The colder weather might slow decomposition a bit, but it also keeps smells and scavengers in check while heavy scraps soften. Come spring, you’ll have organic gold ready for quick absorption in your beds and borders.

Set the Table for Foodie Scraps

Adding these gourmet foodie scraps to garden beds doesn't require expensive or tricky equipment, but it does rely on getting your composting pile in decent shape before the ground freezes. It’s not a good idea to just fold these foodie scraps directly into the soil: composting gives a more efficient (and hygienic) flow of nutrients. Still, all you need is a composting pile, some time, and a little patience.

Dense, wet food waste needs plenty of carbon packed tightly around it to prevent the heap from turning sour or overly saturated. Fall provides the ultimate solution, as fallen leaves are free, and starting to appear everywhere. Layer 2 parts of dry, shredded leaves to 1 part rich kitchen food scraps to keep microbes alive through early frosts. Bury the wet stuff toward the center of your compost pile and keep those leafy browns around it, and the months ahead should take care of the rest.

While you’re waiting for the following gourmet scraps to break down in your compost pile, there are a couple of foodie extras worth adding now. Fall is the ideal season to introduce ocean-derived tonics. Seaweed and kelp are vital soil superfoods, packed with over 60 trace minerals, growth hormones, and enzymes.

For a hearty pop of seaweed, you can add tonics and powders such as Down to Earth Organic Kelp Meal, available from Amazon to give quicker benefits for soil health. Another great soil treatment to add now is mushroom compost. You can get lush ready-made bags of Espoma Natural Mushroom Blend Fertilizer, available from Walmart, to replenish tired autumn beds. This is a great way of priming the ground in readiness for the following treats.

1. Crushed Shellfish Shells

Crustacean shells from the likes of crap or shrimp bring a unique defense that standard veggie peels cannot match. The hard exoskeletons of wild blue crabs, Gulf shrimp, and Maine lobsters are rich in calcium carbonate and a complex carb called chitin. When buried in warm fall compost, chitin triggers a bloom of bacteria that release chitinase. Those same enzymes go after the egg casings of destructive root-knot nematodes (Meloidogyne spp.) lurking in garden soil.

To extract this goodness safely without inviting cats or raccoons, rinse off any heavy salts or seasonings first. Crush the dried shells using a mallet or rolling pin, until you get fine, coin-sized fragments. Bury these deep in the hot center of your pile with plenty of carbon. Then give them 4-6 months to soften. For a quick, pre-ground alternative that delivers instant chitin to beds, you can dust your rows now with a commercial blend such as Neptune's Harvest Organic Crab & Shell Meal from Walmart, which is high in natural chitin and calcium, and a little goes a long way.

2. Artisanal Beer Lees & Stale Crusty Bread

That flat inch (2.5cm) of craft IPA at the bottom of a bottle, the dregs of a rich autumn stout, or the forgotten heel of a sourdough loaf are massively useful. Used well, they hand soil microbes a supply of quick-release sugars and active yeasts in a form that is usable straight away. Cool fall weather can stall microbial activity in your compost, but these carbohydrates and live yeast can help jumpstart things, generating internal thermal energy that keeps the core of your heap warm enough to continue breaking down material well into November.

You can pour beer directly across dry, carbon-rich leaf layers, where it absorbs instantly into the material without pooling. Crusty breads, brioche, or stale dinner rolls must be torn into small chunks and buried at least 8-12 inches (10-25cm) deep within the core of the heap. Left too near the surface, damp bread can mold over and attract rodents. To fast-track the breakdown of bakery waste before adding it to your pile, you can use a tabletop composting or dehydrating unit, such as the Airthereal Revive R500 Electric Kitchen Composter, available from Amazon. This compact countertop food waste recycler easily dehydrates and grinds scraps.

3. Toasted Pecan, Pistachio & Hazelnut Shell

While soft kitchen scraps decompose in a single season, unsalted nut shells (such as crushed pecan hulls, hazelnut shells, and pistachio casings) provide a long-term benefit. Made of woody lignin, crushed nut shells take a year or more to break down. Tilled into beds, these fragments prevent heavy winter clay soil from packing tight under heavy rain and melting snow. Just make sure shells aren’t salted and give them a rinse, since sodium can build up in soil and damage delicate roots.

Word to the wise, avoid using black walnut (Juglans nigra) hulls. Black walnuts contain a natural herbicide called juglone that persists through composting and can stunt or kill sensitive nightshades like tomatoes, peppers, and eggplants in spring. To build a moisture-retentive humus around your shells, layer your heap with some worm castings. Sta-Green Earthworm Castings from Lowe’s are a gentle, slow-release way of building a balanced humus around these nutty extras.

4. Finely Grated Avocado Pits

Toss an avocado pit into a standard compost bin and it will still be sitting there, virtually unchanged, 2 years later. However, beneath that rock-hard outer skin sits a stash of concentrated potassium, nitrogen, and essential fatty acids to power a growing tree seedling (and plenty else besides). The secret to unlocking those nutrients is changing the physical surface area of your pit before it dries out. In other words, get your grater out.

Freshly harvested pits from Hass, Reed, or Bacon avocados are surprisingly soft and easily processed. Use a heavy-duty manual box grater for this job. If you haven’t got one, the Farberware Pro 9.5 Stainless Steel Steel Box Grater from Walmart is a great heavy-duty option for easy (and satisfying) pit shredding. You need to shred the moist pit into nut-like shavings. Scattered into your fall compost or buried beneath bed mulch, these shavings break down in 60-90 days, releasing potassium just in time to power heavy-feeding spring perennials.

5. Charred Fish Bones & Seafood Scraps

The bits of fish we don’t tend to eat (heads, frames, skins) represent some of the richest natural nitrogen sources a home compost heap can ever receive. While soft tissues break down rapidly to feed nitrogen-hungry soil microbes, the calcium-dense fish bones function as slow-release bone meal. As soil acids slowly dissolve these bones over winter, they release phosphorus and calcium, essential building blocks for spring heavy-feeders like dahlias, roses, and tomatoes.

Animal proteins carry a potent scent during initial decomposition. Dig a trench 12-15 inches (30-38cm) deep into the center of a hot compost pile. Lay down the fish scrap, and cap it with a foot (30cm) of shredded leaves or straw. To monitor whether your pile is generating enough heat, you can track internal temps using a compost thermometer. The REOTEMP Backyard Compost Thermometer, available from Amazon, is a reliable probe with an easy-to-follow dial that tells you whether the middle of the heap is running hot enough.

For growers who want the benefits of fish and bone meal in a quicker way, or don’t want to handle raw fish frames, you can also work a handful of Espoma Organic Bio-Tone Starter Plus, available from Walmart, directly into fall planting holes.

6. Pomegranate, Persimmon & Exotic Citrus

Citrus has a reputation for wrecking compost which is unfair. It is believed their natural acidity and d-limonene oils will destroy compost piles or kill beneficial earthworms. While high concentrations of pure citrus oil can bother worms in confined vermicomposting bins, a moderate mix of rinds such as blood orange, Meyer lemon or key lime, or thick pomegranate husks, will be safe for outdoor heaps. Pomegranate husks and thick winter citrus skins are packed with polyphenols, potassium, and trace minerals that enrich winter soil as they soften.

The acidity in citrus peels breaks down rapidly as microbes process the organic matter, and surrounding carbon buffers the pH. To speed up the breakdown of leathery pomegranate husks and grapefruit peels, chop them into small one-inch (2.5cm) pieces before burying them toward the center of your heap. To give tough, leathery fruit rinds an extra boost over cool autumn months, sprinkle the pile with a little compost accelerator, like Roebic Compost Accelerator from Amazon, to double the rate of breakdown before winter. For what it’s worth, these fruity scraps also add a splash of jaunty fall color to your compost heap.

Winter Care for the Big Freeze

Remember to pack your food scraps in carbon, following that 2:1 ratio for crushed fall leaves and foodie bits. Once gourmet scraps and carbon layers are stacked in the pile, the biggest mistake is leaving the compost heap exposed to freezing winter winds. This can chill the outer edges and stall decomposition. A thick 12-inch (30cm) cap of loose straw, clean hay, or dry autumn leaves laid over the top of the bin acts as a thermal blanket, trapping internal heat and moisture.

Turning matters less now than in July, and a well-layered pile can sit until March. Letting the layered pile sit undisturbed protects the warm microbial core. When the middle needs loosening, the Tumbleweed Compost Aerator from The Home Depot can save a lot of digging in cold, packed material. This handy spiral tool makes light work of aerating dense piles. By the time the beds get turned in spring, your lush foodie scraps will be ready to nourish a new year of plants, flowers and crops!

Need more ideas for getting the most from your plants, indoors and out, and looking for the best seasonal expert advice delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for the free Gardening Know How Newsletter!