Most Gardeners Make These 3 Seed-Ordering Mistakes in January – Don't Be One of Them!
Don't click buy until you read this!
Liz Baessler
Ordering seeds in January sparks the season with fresh possibilities. Glossy pages tempt us with endless colors, shapes, and yields, and it’s easy to fill a digital cart before your garden plans are even solid.
The rush builds fast as you flip through pages of potential, but real gardens have physical limits. Thoughtful seed choices keep that excitement grounded. By matching specific varieties to your actual space, you ensure those "color pops" and "flavor bursts" you order in January actually make it to your dinner table.
1. Ordering Way Too Much
Catalogs are designed to be irresistible. When you see dozen of tomato varieties, multicolored carrots, and exotic herbs, they can all feel like essentials. This is how orders rapidly expand beyond the size of your actual garden plots.
Novelty items – those enticing purple-podded beans or striped beets from Burpee – often eclipse reliable standards in the heat of the moment. High-quality photos of vibrant blooms evoke visions of abundance, making it hard to pass anything up. However, without a plan, you end up with a strained budget and a stack of unused packets gathering dust.
How to Stay Realistic
Before you click buy, measure your garden beds and sketch out a layout that accounts for paths and supports. Remember that one seed packet often contains enough for multiple years if stored in a cool, dry place.
Be aware of spacing, and prioritize the ones you actually like to eat. If you have limited space, remember that a tomato plant needs 2-3 feet (60-90 cm) of room, while lettuce only needs 6-8 inches (15-20 cm). Initial restraint leads to a productive garden rather than an overcrowded, leggy mess.
2. Ignoring the Facts
Catalog photos show "ideal" crops, but there's no guarantee your garden matches that ideal. A long-season melon may excel in southern climates and never ripen in a shorter Northern season.
Soil temperature, frost dates, and "days to maturity" are critical details you find in a seed's description. If you live in a windy area, your soil will dry out faster; if you are in an urban "heat island," your plants might stay warmer at night than those in rural fields.
How to Match Seeds to Your Zone
- Check the Stats: Consult the USDA hardiness zone map and look for "early-maturing" varieties if your growing season is short.
- Factor in Microclimates: South-facing slopes warm up earlier, while low-lying spots tend to trap cold air.
- Use Protection: If you want to push the limits of your zone, consider using row covers like these or a greenhouse like this, both from Amazon, to add several weeks to your season.
3. Misunderstanding Buzzwords
It’s easy to gloss over technical terms when you're excited, but those words dictate how your garden will function. For example:
- Indeterminate: These plants vine continuously and need tall, sturdy cages.
- Determinate: These stay bushy and contained, making them perfect for pots.
- Vigorous: A polite way of saying the plant might take over the whole garden!
- F1 Hybrid: These offer great disease resistance, but you can't save the seeds to plant next year (they won't grow "true to type").
Shop Your Own Inventory First
Before ordering anything new, organize your existing seeds. Keep in mind that seed viability declines over time – onions usually last only one year, while beans can last three.
Perform a simple viability test by placing a few seeds in a damp paper towel. If they don't sprout, toss them. Taking ten minutes to inventory what you already have prevents you from buying duplicates and ensures every packet you order has a clear purpose.
Ready to Buy? We Recommend These Great Sellers
